Zirconium stable isotope fractionation during intra-crustal magmatic differentiation in an active continental arc

Zirconium (Zr) stable isotope variations occur among co-existing Zr-rich accessory phases as well as at the bulk-rock scale, but the petrologic mechanism(s) responsible for Zr isotope fractionation during magmatic differentiation remain unclear. Juvenile magma generation and intra-crustal differentiation in convergent continental margins may play a crucial role in developing Zr isotope variations, and the Northern Volcanic Zone of the Andes is an ideal setting to test this hypothesis. To investigate the influence of these processes on Zr stable isotope compositions, we report δ^94/90Zr_NIST of whole rock samples from: 1) juvenile arc basalts from the Quaternary Granatifera Tuff, Colombia; 2) lower crust-derived garnet pyroxenites (i.e., arclogites), hornblendites, and gabbroic cumulates found in the same unit; and 3) felsic volcanic products from the Doña Juana Volcanic Complex, a dacitic composite volcano in close proximity to and partially covering the Granatifera Tuff. The basalts have δ^94/90Zr_NIST values ranging from −0.025 ± 0.018 ‰ to +0.003 ± 0.015 ‰ (n = 8), within the range of mid-ocean ridge basalts. The dacites have δ^94/90Zr_NIST values ranging from +0.008 ± 0.013 ‰ to +0.043 ± 0.015 ‰ (n = 14), slightly positive relative to the Granatifera and mid-ocean ridge basalts. In contrast, the (ultra)mafic cumulates have highly variable, predominantly positive δ^94/90Zr_NIST values, ranging from −0.134 ± 0.012 ‰ to +0.428 ± 0.012 ‰ (n = 15). Individual grains and mineral fractions of major rock-forming phases, including garnet (n = 21), amphibole (n = 9), and clinopyroxene (n = 18), were analyzed from 8 (ultra)mafic cumulates. The mineral fractions record highly variable Zr isotopic compositions, with inter-mineral fractionation (Δ^94/90Zr_{garnet-amphibole}) up to 2.067 ‰. Recent ab initio calculations of Zr–O bond force constants in rock-forming phases predict limited inter-mineral Zr isotope fractionation in high-temperature environments, suggesting that the large fractionations we observe are not the product of vibrational equilibrium processes. Instead, we propose a scenario in which large Zr isotopic fractionations develop kinetically, induced by sub-solidus Zr diffusion between coexisting phases via changes in Zr distribution coefficients that arise from changes in temperature. Altogether, Zr isotope variability in this calc-alkaline continental arc setting exhibits no correlation with indices of magmatic differentiation (e.g., Mg#, SiO₂), and is not a simple function of fractional crystallization. Furthermore, the garnet clinopyroxenite cumulates studied here represent density-unstable lower arc crust material; consequently, material with isotopically variable δ^94/90Zr can be recycled into the mantle as a consequence of lower crustal foundering.