The sandia fracture challenge: Blind round robin predictions of ductile tearing

B. L. Boyce, S. L.B. Kramer, H. E. Fang, T. E. Cordova, M. K. Neilsen, K. Dion, A. K. Kaczmarowski, E. Karasz, L. Xue, A. J. Gross, A. Ghahremaninezhad, K. Ravi-Chandar, S. P. Lin, S. W. Chi, J. S. Chen, E. Yreux, M. Rüter, D. Qian, Z. Zhou, S. BhamareD. T. O'Connor, S. Tang, K. I. Elkhodary, J. Zhao, J. D. Hochhalter, A. R. Cerrone, A. R. Ingraffea, P. A. Wawrzynek, B. J. Carter, J. M. Emery, M. G. Veilleux, P. Yang, Y. Gan, X. Zhang, Z. Chen, E. Madenci, B. Kilic, T. Zhang, E. Fang, P. Liu, J. Lua, K. Nahshon, M. Miraglia, J. Cruce, R. Defrese, E. T. Moyer, S. Brinckmann, L. Quinkert, K. Pack, M. Luo, T. Wierzbicki

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

99 Scopus citations


Existing and emerging methods in computational mechanics are rarely validated against problems with an unknown outcome. For this reason, Sandia National Laboratories, in partnership with US National Science Foundation and Naval Surface Warfare Center Carderock Division, launched a computational challenge in mid-summer, 2012. Researchers and engineers were invited to predict crack initiation and propagation in a simple but novel geometry fabricated from a common off-the-shelf commercial engineering alloy. The goal of this international Sandia Fracture Challenge was to benchmark the capabilities for the prediction of deformation and damage evolution associated with ductile tearing in structural metals, including physics models, computational methods, and numerical implementations currently available in the computational fracture community. Thirteen teams participated, reporting blind predictions for the outcome of the Challenge. The simulations and experiments were performed independently and kept confidential. The methods for fracture prediction taken by the thirteen teams ranged from very simple engineering calculations to complicated multiscale simulations. The wide variation in modeling results showed a striking lack of consistency across research groups in addressing problems of ductile fracture. While some methods were more successful than others, it is clear that the problem of ductile fracture prediction continues to be challenging. Specific areas of deficiency have been identified through this effort. Also, the effort has underscored the need for additional blind prediction-based assessments.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)5-68
Number of pages64
JournalInternational Journal of Fracture
Issue number1-2
StatePublished - Mar 2014


  • Crack initiation
  • Damage
  • Deformation
  • Ductility
  • Failure
  • Fracture
  • Tearing

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Computational Mechanics
  • Modeling and Simulation
  • Mechanics of Materials


Dive into the research topics of 'The sandia fracture challenge: Blind round robin predictions of ductile tearing'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this