State neutrality and controversial values in on liberty

Gerald F. Gaus

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

12 Scopus citations


I MILL: A “COMPREHENSIVE” DEFENSE OF LIBERAL NEUTRALITY?: In an important essay Charles Larmore tells us that, Kant and Mill sought to justify the principle of political neutrality by appealing to ideals of autonomy and individuality. By remaining neutral with regard to controversial views of the good life, constitutional principles will express, according to them, what ought to be of supreme value throughout the whole of our life, On Larmore's influential reading, Mill defended what we might call first-level neutrality: Millian principles determining justified legal (and, we might add, social) intervention are neutral between competing conceptions of the good life. However, Larmore insists that Millian neutral political principles do not possess second-level neutrality: they do not have a neutral justification. “The problem with Mill's value-based defense of liberalism,” Larmore holds, is that because the value of individuality is “far from uncontroversial,” Mill's case liberalism is open to reasonable objection. In contrast Larmore and, of course, John Rawls, seek to develop a “political liberalism” that defends liberal neutrality without appeal to a “general ‘philosophy of man’ or a ‘comprehensive moral ideal.’” The justification of liberal principles “must be acceptable by reasonable people having different views of the good life, not just those who share, for example, Mill's ideal of the person.” Liberals, argues Larmore, need “a neutral justification of neutrality.”, This chapter challenges this widely accepted view of Mill as presenting a “comprehensive” defense of liberalism, to be sharply contrasted with the “political liberalism” of Larmore and Rawls.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Title of host publicationMill's On Liberty
Subtitle of host publicationA Critical Guide
PublisherCambridge University Press
Number of pages22
ISBN (Electronic)9780511575181
ISBN (Print)9780521873567
StatePublished - Jan 1 2009

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Arts and Humanities(all)


Dive into the research topics of 'State neutrality and controversial values in on liberty'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this