Computing Robust Optimal Factories in Metabolic Reaction Networks

Perhaps the most fundamental model in synthetic and systems biology for inferring pathways in metabolic reaction networks is a metabolic factory: a system of reactions that starts from a set of source compounds and produces a set of target molecules, while conserving or not depleting intermediate metabolites. Finding a shortest factory—that minimizes a sum of real-valued weights on its reactions to infer the most likely pathway—is NP-complete. The current state-of-the-art for shortest factories solves a mixed-integer linear program with a major drawback: it requires the user to set a critical parameter, where too large a value can make optimal solutions infeasible, while too small a value can yield degenerate solutions due to numerical error. We present the first robust algorithm for optimal factories that is both parameter-free (relieving the user from determining a parameter setting) and degeneracy-free (guaranteeing it finds an optimal nondegenerate solution). We also give for the first time a complete characterization of the graph-theoretic structure of shortest factories via cuts of hypergraphs that reveals two important classes of degenerate solutions which were overlooked and potentially output by the prior state-of-the-art. In addition we settle the relationship between the two established pathway models of hyperpaths and factories by proving that hyperpaths are actually a subclass of factories. Comprehensive experiments over all instances from the standard metabolic reaction databases in the literature demonstrate our algorithm is fast in practice, quickly finding optimal factories in large real-world networks containing thousands of reactions. A preliminary implementation of our algorithm for robust optimal factories in a new tool called Freeia is available free for research use at http://freeia.cs.arizona.edu.